5. Integrative Thinking and ePortfolios

 

Productive Assessment l Professional Development l Planning: Visions, Strategies l Boundary Crossing
LTAs - Low Threshold Applications l Nanovation Bookmarks l Individual Members Resources
Home Page: Implications of IT for the Shape of a College Education

The fifth of the five defining outcomes of a liberal education as described by the Association of American Colleges and Universities: 

5)   Habits of mind that foster integrative thinking and the ability to transfer skills and knowledge from one setting to another—achieved and demonstrated through advanced research and/or creative projects in which students take the primary responsibility for framing questions, carrying out an analysis, and producing work of substantial complexity and quality.

Among the more important strategies for fostering integrative thinking are capstone courses and ePortfolios. Technology can play roles in both by a) making it possible for students to work on more complex, interdisciplinary and motivating projects, and b) making it possible for there to be an audience or users of the student's work going beyond an individual faculty member.

The references below have been selected to help you thinking about how to use ePortfolios.

  • Alverno College's Digital Diagnostic Portfolio was one of the first web-based system that made it easy for students and faculty to examine progress of students toward institution's goals for general education and the major.

  • Indiana University Purdue University Indianapolis (IUPUI) defined six Principles of Undergraduate Learning (PULs) in 1998: learning outcomes such as communications skill and critical thinking that are supposed to emerge from the totality of the undergraduate's education, not just general education courses or the first two years of the program.  Created in part due to pressure from regional accreditors, the PULs provided the groundwork both for a common core curriculum. All courses were supposed to use the PULs in crafting their syllabi.  Observation that this inclusion was sometimes perfunctory "reinforced the need to determine the extent to which the PULs were playing a significant role in .. undergraduate learning," said Prof. Sharon Hamilton of IUPUI. Hamilton was asked to head a committee that would study the emerging curriculum and make recommendations.  The committee suggested building on iPort, IUPUI's institutional portfolio program by creating ePort, a portfolio program for undergraduates. Six faculty communities of practice have now also been organized, one for each PUL.  Hamilton, Associate Dean of the Faculty and in charge of the ePort effort, sees many impacts of this combination of PULs, ePortfolio, and faculty communities of practice, including a more coherent view of learning by both students and faculty, more emphasis on student projects and documentation of student work with audio and video, and a framework and process more open to change (e.g., evolving definition of student communication skills so that more emphasis is put on student ability to community using the multimedia and linking capabilities of the Web). Hamilton wrote about this initiative in "A Principle-Based Approach to Assessing General Education,” Journal of General Education. 52:4 2004. 283-303. Click here for the text of her article.

  • What do students need to learn in order to create effective portfolios? This report from Janice Fournier at the University of Washington reports on research on this topic. UW's Catalyst Program ran a competition for student portfolios. The report summarizes criteria developed for a close study of these portfolios.

  • TLT Group subscriber resource: EPortfolio software is a means to help students and others do things differently. The TLT Group has developed a guide for formative evaluation of ePortfolio initiatives: in other words, a guide to gathering the kinds of data that can help a program succeed in doing things differently with that ePortfolio software. For example, suppose one of your goals is to have more outside assessment of student work.  Formative evaluation would track who is assessing student work and analyze reasons why some students are getting more outside feedback than other students do on their portfolios. If your institution is a TLT Group subscriber, click here to see the Flashlight Guide to Planning and Formative Evaluation of E-Portfolio Initiatives; you'll need your institution's username and password for our web site..  If your institution is not yet a subscriber, click here to see the first draft of this Guide.

  • General background about ePortfolios:

    • Electronic Portfolios: Emerging Practices in Student, Faculty, and Institutional Learning,  Washington, D.C. AAHE, 2001 (Barbara Cambridge, Susan Kahn, Kathleen Blake Yancey).  This is the first published compendium of information about a wide range of electronic portfolios. It captures the early days of electronic portfolio conceptualization and design, and discusses both potential and pitfalls. It is still timely for those considering adopting or developing an electronic portfolio.

    • North Carolina State has an extensive resource page on assessment. Search on the word "portfolio" to see a variety of resources, including a listserv.

  • Does your institution use technology in this way, or other ways, to help students learn to pull the pieces together and apply what they've learned in one field to problems in another field? Please send your suggestions for this web site to Steve Ehrmann (ehrmann@tlgroup.org)

  • For a related TLT Group web page on the use of student e-portfolios to help faculty guide students' education and reshape the academic program, click here.

Home Page: Implications of IT for the Shape of a College Education

Some Rights Reserved:  "Share it Forward" Creative Commons License by the TLT Group, a Non-Profit Corp.

PO Box 5643,
Takoma Park, Maryland 20913
Phone
: 301.270.8312/Fax: 301.270.8110  

To talk about our work
or our organization
contact:  Sally Gilbert

Search TLT Group.org

Contact us | Partners | TLTRs | FridayLive! | Consulting | 7 Principles | LTAs | TLT-SWG | Archives | Site Map |